I've seen posts where people used an aftermarket two piece one; just not sure which brand.
Also saw some Ford ones on Ebay.
What's the best route to go?
I've bought exactly one trim piece for my '04 because the PO had drilled a hole in the shifter bezel. I ordered a new one from CJ Pony parts and it was identical to the OEM piece right down to the tooling and mold marks, and molded part numbers in the back. I mean mirror image. It was clearly made from the same tooling and molds.