My best friend and his GF went to the Dominican Republic like 2 years ago and stayed at an all inclusive, they were less than impressed and never felt safe.
My parents go to all inclusive resorts often and aren't afraid to spend way too much. They said the Sandals Ochi in Jamaica was ok, mostly they enjoyed the service they got from one of the workers. It's unfortunate that Mexico is off the list, they said the Secrets Moroma was the best resort they have ever been to. I think it helped that they went around Christmas, so there were a lot less people than normal but everything from the food, to the service to the amenities were all absolutely top notch.
My parents go to all inclusive resorts often and aren't afraid to spend way too much. They said the Sandals Ochi in Jamaica was ok, mostly they enjoyed the service they got from one of the workers. It's unfortunate that Mexico is off the list, they said the Secrets Moroma was the best resort they have ever been to. I think it helped that they went around Christmas, so there were a lot less people than normal but everything from the food, to the service to the amenities were all absolutely top notch.