i have a 2.3 whipple and mine hit 18psi
Well I'll throw this out. IT'S ALL IN THE TUNE!!!!! It's great that people want to blame thier motor blowing on 91 octane. Fact is there are quite a few people running 18lbs on 91 with no problems. I even know a guy out here that runs 21lbs on straight 91 octane. I believe his SN is NITROSCOBRA. Talk to him, I personally wouldn't run more than 18 but he has a ton of miles on his setup running 21lbs on 91 octane with a 3.4 whipple. There's no doubt that the motor is on the edge now, but he runs 91 just fine right now.
Just my .02
Talk to a reputable tuner and go with their recommendation. I've read lots of posts of people running tons of boost on low octane fuel, but I wouldn't do it! My shop (AED in Sacramento) installed a 3.5" upper (stock lower) on my Whipple for 91... I don't remember exactly, but I think it is somewhere around 13 or 14 pounds. Hopefully my engine will last a while and I don't have to worry about getting a bad tank of gas.
I use a 2.75" upper for 104 octane, which I believe is around 18 pounds. I also would not recommend using 100 octane from a pump- it sits down there a long time so there's a high risk of it going bad.