I used the Metco pulley with the spacers in the kit plus washers to shim the tensioner.I'm curious as to what pulley you used on the roush tensioner? When I upgraded to the roush part I wanted a metco pulley, simply to match the rest of my pulleys. They said they didn't have one that would fit.
I assume you spaced the roush tensioner correctly? It doesn't just bolt on, it needs spacers