Just got a motor build quote and have questions

Weather Man

Persistance Is A Bitch
Established Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
25,996
Location
MN
HP is expensive. If you are really shooting for 1,000 RWHP, stick with I beam rods and specced wrist pins.
 

Corbic

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Premium Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2015
Messages
11,417
Location
Desert Oasis
I still feel building a 4.6/5.4 with a Turbo to 1k hp is way cheaper.

The 5.8 is a rare unique monster and building one is not cheap.

In the Audi world the Coated Sleeve V8’s are pretty much considered non-rebuildable for the reasons guys have mentioned here. The coating is to thin to bore/hone to get new rings seated.


Sent from my iPhone using svtperformance.com
 

biminiLX

never stock
Established Member
Premium Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2003
Messages
13,293
Location
Toledo, OH
Lots of good advice on here so far, the first being really analyzing your goals with the car.
I feel the stock motor is safe at 750-800rwhp as long as you respect the octane and RPM.
Outside of that, unless you're going for a street/strip build where you'll actually run it hard at the strip like I do, you'll have more fun on the street at 750rwhp.
At 15,000 miles and asking for a reliable 1000hp you'll be in for a total engine build, and yes 1000hp engines cost big dollars.
You can cut a few options such as the CNC porting and sleeving and significantly reduce the cost, but those are things to discuss with the shop about YOUR plans.
Good luck.
-J
 

quikstang90

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
May 20, 2017
Messages
109
Okay...I'll be the one to ask the obvious question. Why do you think you need 1000 HP? If the goal is to run at the track where you can hook that much power I understand. Other than that I don't get it. Add upper pulley, plugs, throttle body, CAI, Lund tune, long tubes and BMR suspension and you will be over 700 to the rear and be able to use it when needed. Take the $10,000 left over and take a nice trip to Europe and see London, Paris, and Rome.

Car already has a 2.4 upper, plugs, kb 168, pmas 6" lund tune , and kooks long tubes with full kooks exhaust, plus id1050's, bps fuel rails, twin vmp fuel pump boosters, vmp heat exchanger, plus full bmr suspension...... im wanting the power because i recently attended a wanna go fast 1/2 mile event and really enjoyed it and can see myself doing it more. Car was a pretty good performer just want more


Sent from my iPhone using the svtperformance.com mobile app
 

quikstang90

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
May 20, 2017
Messages
109
While I have done every reliability based modification that was available by JDM in October of 2015 my goal was to reach 800 RWHP and have great reliability. I got 806 RWHP with 689 lbs FT torque at 7600 RPM tuned by Jim Sr. on his dyno. After nearly 3000 miles of driving this car with all of the modifications (see mods) I have came to one conclusion. It is impossible to hook this car up with 20" drag radials on the street. It is not going to happen. I have the best suspension set up money can buy and the car goes amazingly straight but the tires will not hold the horsepower period.

These engines are expensive and there is a world of difference in price to build a motor like mine that makes 800 RWHP reliably vs. 1000 RWHP. I do not believe their quote is out of line.

JDM does offer a one year warranty on their builds as long as the motor has not been detonated. Pretty tough to beat this deal!

I have one question for you. How are you going to hook 1000 RWHP up on the street in your current car? If you tell me 15" slicks and skinnies on the front then you do not have a street car but a race car. Just my two cents from someone who knows how much it costs to play this game.

Nope car is still on stock wheels..... which i plan on keeping it that way. I run a nitto nt05r in 315/35/20 on the rear.


Sent from my iPhone using the svtperformance.com mobile app
 

Bad Company

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,956
Location
N/A
I've been down this road twice. One time the engine didn't last more than 325 miles and 5 hours from what a lot of people call a reputable engine builder. The second time there wasn't enough left of the engine to fix without spending a small fortune. In my opinion Tim will quote you exactly what you need for the power you want. His reputation is at stake and he is going to quote you the parts and work to accomplish your Hp goals. can you build it cheaper? Yep, but it could cost you much more if it expires and eats itself afterwards.

The quote is in line for the work being performed. If it was my engine, I'd be spending more on additional parts for the timing chain system and a billet crankshaft.
 

RBB

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
1,354
Location
Stephens City, VA
The quote is in line for the work being performed. If it was my engine, I'd be spending more on additional parts for the timing chain system and a billet crankshaft.
I meant to say this in my first post as well. If you want to make that kind of power, and are concerned about the longevity of the engine, I'd definitely upgrade all timing components. I see you've got the upgraded secondary sprockets and chains, which is only a good starting point.

I'd upgrade the primary sprockets and chains to the larger GT/Navi components which will require you to get some new valve covers and have them customized. Also add the upgraded passenger side tensioner and you may even want to look into billet timing chain guides (still optional, IMO). You may also want to look into have all the timing components microblued.
 

sleek98

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Messages
2,170
Location
Kansas City, MO
Good God. $20k for a longblock is nuts.

Wish i had the money you guys do!

Yeah long gone are the cheap days of building a motor.

I am almost tempted to pull my short block and put in a built iron block. This way if I grenade the motor I still have the stock on in the corner to put back in. I guess I need to look at the cost to see what that would even save, if any.
 

gimmie11s

I Race Pontiacs
Established Member
Premium Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2004
Messages
18,627
Location
la la land
Yeah long gone are the cheap days of building a motor.

I am almost tempted to pull my short block and put in a built iron block. This way if I grenade the motor I still have the stock on in the corner to put back in. I guess I need to look at the cost to see what that would even save.


Bingo. A 1500hp capable iron 5.4 is $4k.

These al motor prices just seem like such a price gouge for the 5.8 guys!
 

Black02GT

*Not 2KBlackGT
Established Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2004
Messages
6,229
Location
NY
I've been down this road twice. One time the engine didn't last more than 325 miles and 5 hours from what a lot of people call a reputable engine builder. The second time there wasn't enough left of the engine to fix without spending a small fortune. In my opinion Tim will quote you exactly what you need for the power you want. His reputation is at stake and he is going to quote you the parts and work to accomplish your Hp goals. can you build it cheaper? Yep, but it could cost you much more if it expires and eats itself afterwards.

The quote is in line for the work being performed. If it was my engine, I'd be spending more on additional parts for the timing chain system and a billet crankshaft.

Care to share who? It seems you can't be PMed.
 

JimIII@jdm

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2003
Messages
1,953
Location
NJ
I just wanted to jump in and say thanks to some of the guys who mentioned JDM Engineering. We do build a lot of 5.8's and some of the guys who've posted in here and on this forum are great examples of what we can do!

I looked at the estimate really quick and it's right on par, a few things we do different...but every artist paint's a different picture. It's best to call and get estimates and speak to the shops your looking at to get more knowledge about this sort of upgrade. It isn't cheap, but it is alot cheaper than having to build an entirely new engine if you grenade your's. The block and heads bare castings alone cost north of $10,000 from Ford.

To make 1000 HP (800-850 RWHP) vs. 1000 RWHP is a big jump. It requires additional upgrades to the timing components, valve train, and more. Not to mention the fuel system and other components out side of the engine it will require. If that is your goal and to do it safely you can easily approach 30K parts and labor.

If you have any questions or need an estimate from us just give me a shout at the office 732-780-0770 or email [email protected] We would be more than happy to discuss specifics and options.

Thanks,

JimIII@JDM
 

Weather Man

Persistance Is A Bitch
Established Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
25,996
Location
MN
Care to share who? It seems you can't be PMed.

First motor was L&M contracted through Evolution. OP had the thread deleted, it was a shit show. Didn't know he popped the replacement motor to that, that was supposed to be a high buck uber 1st rate effort.
 

RBB

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
1,354
Location
Stephens City, VA
First motor was L&M contracted through Evolution. OP had the thread deleted, it was a shit show. Didn't know he popped the replacement motor to that, that was supposed to be a high buck uber 1st rate effort.
He didn't pop the second one. That build isn't even complete yet.
 

Weather Man

Persistance Is A Bitch
Established Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
25,996
Location
MN
He didn't pop the second one. That build isn't even complete yet.

"Bad Company -- I've been down this road twice. One time the engine didn't last more than 325 miles and 5 hours from what a lot of people call a reputable engine builder. The second time there wasn't enough left of the engine to fix without spending a small fortune."

Maybe the 2nd motor that popped wasn't a GT500 ?
 

RBB

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
1,354
Location
Stephens City, VA
"Bad Company -- I've been down this road twice. One time the engine didn't last more than 325 miles and 5 hours from what a lot of people call a reputable engine builder. The second time there wasn't enough left of the engine to fix without spending a small fortune."

Maybe the 2nd motor that popped wasn't a GT500 ?
He means the second build....there wasn't enough left of the original L&M built engine left to fix. Second build is still not complete.
 

Bad Company

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,956
Location
N/A
Care to share who? It seems you can't be PMed.
L & M built the first engine that didn't survive.

I don't understand why I can't receive a Personal Message, I don't have anything turned off in my profile that can do this. I don't even know if I can turn off receiving PMs in the first place. I do know I can add people to an ignore list, but I don't have anyone listed in that portion of my profile. It wouldn't surprise me if my account was altered in some other manner though.

Someone send me a PM to see how this works.
 

Bad Company

Well-Known Member
Established Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,956
Location
N/A
"Bad Company -- I've been down this road twice. One time the engine didn't last more than 325 miles and 5 hours from what a lot of people call a reputable engine builder. The second time there wasn't enough left of the engine to fix without spending a small fortune."

Maybe the 2nd motor that popped wasn't a GT500 ?
I'be been through 2 builds of the 5.8L engine.

I have NOT blown two 5.8L engines.

The second built engine hasn't been fired up yet. The engine is back in the chassis. I'm still progressing with some modifications to the car to to reap the full benefits of this second built engine. If I'm lucky it may fire before the end of this year........but my luck with this car has never been good. I hoping it will be running in the spring.

The costs of building any GT500 engine to 1000RWHP as Jim said is expensive. These engine are very hard on timing chain components if you use a 2 step/WOT box or bang the engine against the Rev Limiter. I've also seen them break the primary timing chains when guys do big wheel stands at the track and pedal the throttle hard to try to set the front tires down gently. This is rare but it happens because of how much grip the tires have at the moment versus how fast the driver tries to get off and back on the throttle to keep the front end from slamming the ground hard. I've seen this happen twice over the years. This is what a few of my detractors said caused my first engine to fail. Unfortunately they weren't sitting along side me in the passengers seat to see this isn't what happened.
 

Users who are viewing this thread



Top