I was always told that premium gas is only better if your car is tuned for it. My brother was telling me he puts Shell premium in his stock Mazda 6 and gets noticeably better gas mileage. So I try it in my truck, non s/c hd f150, and I got 1-2 mpg more than I usually do. Not a bad gain when your at 14mpg. The only thing that I can think of is maybe it doesn't have ethanol in it? So what do you guys use?