I doubt they were casing your area because of the time of night and it being a Friday night. 1a on a Tuesday night - yes, 9p on a Friday night, probably just some lost dumb asses, but you never know.
This. I would have greeted him with the gun the first time.
As for calling the police, I see you are from Ohio. Idk about Ohio, but in Arizona the police only come out if they are actively trying to break in.
Update: I called TPD and reported it.
I wouldn't be shocked if he was actually trying to steal gas. Years ago I was sitting on the sofa watching tv and saw a reflection in the sliding glass door. I jumped up to see this clown easing out of my yard with my gas can. I ran him down before he got to the road. His excuse was he didn't think anyone was home. He told me he ran out of gas and was going to fill it up and bring it right back. Then he spilled the beans and told me who he was. His sister lived right down the road. He got a boot in the ass and a warning.
I've lost more gas and cans than I can count in the past 20 years. Gas and cans used to be cheap. Now you are looking at $40-50 gone when they walk off with one. I decided to leave them some special gas now. I usually have a couple old cans that have seen better days. When I am working on something, I dump the old stale fuel out in one of these. I add a little sugar and more water for good measure. Then leave it where it would be easily spotted by someone snooping around to steal some gas. Someone took one about four years ago. Haven't had it happen since.
I went to confront them a fourth time with glasses of water(and to collect fingerprints) and they were gone.
As for calling the police, I see you are from Ohio. Idk about Ohio, but in Arizona the police only come out if they are actively trying to break in.
EDIT: Hell the last time time I got into an accident they asked if any was injured. Both parties said no and I quote, "Ok good, because we have more important things coming in over the radio." No report was issued.
U strike me as a cop caller kind of guy... Not a meet the perp with a gun type of guy
^^^ you need to shave.
What, his legs? Glad you looked for something like that besides the weapon, lol. The leash is going to start getting shorter around here.